Introduction
0.1 These Regulations are established pursuant to article 28.10 of the
Company’s articles of association and best practice provision III.1.1 of the
Dutch Corporate Governance Code.
0.2 These Regulations are complementary to the provisions regarding the
Supervisory Board and the Supervisory Board members as contained in applicable
legislation and regulations, the articles of association of the Company and
the rules pertaining to the relationship between Managing Board and
Supervisory Board as contained in the Regulations of the Managing Board (which
have been approved by the Supervisory Board).
0.3 These Regulations are posted on the Company's website.
0.4 The meaning of certain capitalised or uncapitalised terms used in these
Regulations is set forth in the List of Definitions attached as Annex 1.
Chapter 1
Composition of the Supervisory Board; positions;
committees
1. Supervisory Board Profile, Size, Expertise and Independence
1.1 The Supervisory Board shall prepare a profile of its size and composition,
taking account of the nature of the business of the Company and its
Subsidiaries and the desired expertise and background of the Supervisory Board
members (the Supervisory Board Profile). The current Supervisory Board Profile
is attached as Annex 2. The Supervisory Board Profile is made available on
written demand to the Company (for the attention of the Company Secretary) and
is posted on the Company's website.
1.2 The number of Supervisory Board members is determined by the Supervisory
Board after consultation with the Chairman of the Managing Board, and has a
minimum of 5 members.
1.3 The Supervisory Board shall endeavour to ensure, within the limits of its
powers, that it is at all times composed so that:
(a) its members are able to act critically and independently of one another,
the Managing Board and any particular interest;
(b) each Supervisory Board member is capable of assessing the broad outline of
the overall policy of the Company;
(c) each Supervisory Board member has the specific expertise required to
perform his duties within the framework of his role within the Supervisory
Board Profile;
(d) the Supervisory Board as a whole matches the Supervisory Board Profile and
that the composition of the Supervisory Board is such that it is able to carry
out its duties properly;
(e) at least one Supervisory Board member is a financial expert, in the sense
that he has relevant knowledge and expertise of financial administration and
accounting for listed companies or other large companies;
(f) all Supervisory Board members, with the exception of not more than one,
are independent within the meaning of clause 1.4 of these Regulations; and
(g) all Supervisory Board members observe the restrictions regarding the
nature and number of their other positions as set forth in clause 21.1 of
these Regulations.
1.4 A Supervisory Board member is deemed independent if the following criteria
of dependence do not apply to him. These criteria are that the Supervisory
Board member concerned, his spouse, registered partner or other life
companion, foster child or relative by blood or marriage up to the second
degree:
(a) has been an employee or member of the Managing Board of the Company or an
affiliated company in the five years prior to their appointment as Supervisory
Board member;
(b) receives personal financial compensation from the Company, or an
affiliated company, other than the compensation received for the work
performed as a Supervisory Board member and in so far as this is not keeping
with the ordinary business operations;
(c) has had an important business relationship with the Company or an
affiliated company in the year prior to the appointment;
(d) is a member of the Managing board of a company in which a member of the
Managing Board is a supervisory board member;
(e) holds at least ten per cent of the shares in the Company's capital
(including shares held by natural or legal persons that cooperate with the
individual concerned under an express, tacit, oral or written agreement);
(f) is a member of the Managing board or supervisory board, or a
representative in some other way, of a legal entity which holds at least ten
per cent of the shares in the Company's capital, unless such entity is a
member of the same group as the Company; or
(g) has temporarily managed the Company during the previous twelve months due
to vacant seats on the Managing Board, or because Managing Board members were
unable to perform their duties.
2. (Re)Appointment; Term of Office; Resignation
2.1 The members of the Supervisory Board are appointed by the General Meeting
of Shareholders. The Supervisory Board nominates one or more candidates for
appointment.
2.2 A nomination or recommendation to the General Meeting of Shareholders to
appoint a Supervisory Board member shall state the candidate's age, his
profession, the amount of the shares he holds in the Company's capital and the
positions he holds or has held, insofar as these are relevant for the
performance of the duties of a Supervisory Board member. Furthermore, the
legal entities of whose supervisory boards he is also a member of must be
listed; if those include legal entities which belong to the same group,
reference to that group is sufficient. The recommendation or nomination for
appointment or reappointment shall state the reasons on which it is based.
2.3 Any nomination or recommendation by the Supervisory Board for appointment
or reappointment of a Supervisory Board member must be in accordance with
clause 1 of these Regulations, including the Supervisory Board Profile. In
case of reappointment, account must be taken of the candidate's past
performance as a Supervisory Board member. A Supervisory Board member is
reappointed only after careful consideration.
2.4 A person may be appointed to the Supervisory Board for a maximum of three
4-year terms.
2.5 Supervisory Board members shall retire periodically in accordance with a
rotation plan to be drawn up by the Supervisory Board in order to avoid, as
far as possible, a situation in which many Supervisory Board members retire at
the same time. The current rotation plan is attached as Annex 3. The
Supervisory Board may at any time amend the rotation plan. Amendments to the
rotation plan, however, do not permit a sitting member of the Supervisory
Board to remain in office for a longer period than appointed for, or allow
that he be asked to retire before his term has expired. The rotation plan is
available on written demand to the Company (for the attention of the Company
Secretary) and is posted on the Company’s website.
2.6 A Supervisory Board member shall retire early in the event of inadequate
performance, structural incompatibility of interests, and in any other
instances where deemed necessary by the Supervisory Board.
2.7 A Supervisory Board member who is temporarily charged with the managing of
the Company when seats on the Managing Board are vacant or Managing Board
members are unable to fulfil their duties, shall resign from the Supervisory
Board.
3. Chairman and Vice-Chairman
3.1 The Supervisory Board shall elect a Chairman and a Vice-Chairman from
among its members. The Vice-Chairman shall replace, and shall assume the
powers and duties of, the Chairman in the latter's absence. The Chairman shall
not be a former member of the Managing Board.
3.2 The Chairman of the Supervisory Board is primarily responsible for the
functioning of the Supervisory Board and its Committees. He shall act as the
spokesman of the Supervisory Board and is the main contact for the Chairman of
the Managing Board and the Managing Board as a whole. The Chairman of the
Managing Board and the Chairman of the Supervisory Board shall meet on a
regular basis. As a general rule, the Chairman of the Supervisory Board
presides over General Meetings of Shareholders.
3.3 Without prejudice to the generality of clause 3.2, the Chairman shall see
to it that:
(a) Supervisory Board members, when appointed, follow the induction programme
and, as needed, additional education or training programmes;
(b) the Supervisory Board members receive all information necessary for the
proper performance of their duties in a timely manner;
(c) there is sufficient time for consultation and decision-making by the
Supervisory Board;
(d) the Committees function properly;
(e) the performance of the Managing Board members and the Supervisory Board
members is assessed at least once a year;
(f) the Supervisory Board elects a Vice-Chairman; and
(g) the Supervisory Board has proper contact with the Managing Board.
3.4 In addition, the Chairman is primarily responsible for:
(a) ensuring the proper discharge by the Supervisory Board of its duties;
(b) determining the agenda of Supervisory Board meetings and chairing such
meetings;
(c) consulting with external advisors appointed by the Supervisory Board;
(d) addressing issues related to the performance of individual Supervisory
Board members; and
(e) addressing internal disputes and conflicts of interest concerning
individual Supervisory Board members and the possible resignation of such
members as a result.
4. Company Secretary
4.1 The Supervisory Board is assisted by the Company Secretary, who is
appointed in accordance with the provisions of clause 4 of the Regulations of
the Managing Board.
4.2 All Supervisory Board members have access to the advice and services of
the Company Secretary.
4.3 The Company Secretary sees to it that correct Supervisory Board procedures
are followed and that the obligations of the Supervisory Board under the law,
as well as the Company’s articles of association are complied with. The
Company Secretary shall assist the Chairman of the Supervisory Board in the
organisation of the affairs of the Supervisory Board (information, agenda,
reporting of meetings, evaluation, training programme, etc.). The Company
Secretary is as such also the secretary of the Supervisory Board.
4.4 The Company Secretary may delegate his duties under these Regulations, or
parts thereof, to a deputy appointed by him in consultation with the Chairman
of the Supervisory Board.
4.5 The Company Secretary also performs activities for the Managing Board, as
provided for in the Regulations of the Managing Board.
5. Committees
5.1 The Supervisory Board may appoint standing and/or ad hoc Committees from
among its members, which are charged with tasks specified by the Supervisory
Board. The composition of any Committee is determined by the Supervisory
Board. The Supervisory Board shall, in any event, establish an Audit
Committee, and a Nomination and Remuneration Committee.
5.2 The Supervisory Board remains collectively responsible for decisions
prepared by Committees from among its members. A Committee may only exercise
such powers as are explicitly attributed or delegated to it and may never
exercise powers beyond those exercisable by the Supervisory Board as a whole.
5.3 Each Committee must inform the Supervisory Board in a clear and timely way
of the manner in which it has used delegated authority and of any major
development in the area of its responsibilities. All Supervisory Board members
have unrestricted access to all Committee meetings and records. The
Supervisory Board shall, within the term specified in the Charter of the
Committee concerned, receive a report from each Committee of its deliberations
and findings.
5.4 The Supervisory Board shall establish Charter for each Committee and may
amend these Charters at any time. The Charter shall indicate the role and
responsibilities of the Committee concerned, its composition and the manner in
which it performs its duties. The Charter of a Committee shall in any event
contain a provision that only one member of the Committee concerned need not
be independent within the meaning of clause 1.4 of these Regulations. The
Charter of a Committee may contain more detailed rules on the composition of
the Committee concerned.
5.5 The Charters and the composition of the Committees are posted on the
Company's website.
5.6 The Supervisory Board as a rule has no "delegated Supervisory Board
member" (gedelegeerd commissaris). Under special circumstances, however, the
Supervisory Board may resolve to appoint a “delegated Supervisory Board
member”, in which case best practice provision III.6.6 of the Dutch Corporate
Governance Code shall apply in full.
Chapter 2
Duties and powers
6. General Duties and Powers; Relation with the Managing Board
6.1 The Supervisory Board is charged with the supervision of the Managing
Board, the general course of affairs of the Company and the business connected
with it. The Supervisory Board assists the Managing Board with advice whether
or not requested. The responsibility for the proper performance of its duties
is vested collectively in the Supervisory Board.
6.2 In performing its duties the Supervisory Board shall act in accordance
with the interests of the Company and the business connected with it, taking
into consideration the interests of the Company's stakeholders. Supervisory
Board members shall perform their duties without mandate and independent of
any interest in the business of the Company. They should not support one
interest without regard to the other interests involved.
6.3 The Supervisory Board is responsible for the quality of its own
performance.
6.4 The Supervisory Board members shall externally express concurring views
with respect to important affairs, matters of principle and matters of general
interest, without jeopardising the responsibilities of individual Supervisory
Board members.
6.5 The Managing Board shall of its own accord and in a timely manner provide
the Supervisory Board and its members and Committees with the information
needed to function and to discharge their duties properly. The information
will as much as possible be provided in writing.
6.6 The Supervisory Board and its individual members each has responsibility
for obtaining all information from the Managing Board and the External Auditor
needed to enable them to carry out their duties properly as a supervisory
body. If deemed necessary by the Supervisory Board, it may obtain information
from officers and external advisers of the Company. The Company shall provide
the necessary means for this purpose. The Supervisory Board may require that
certain officers and external advisers attend its meetings.
6.7 Each member of the Supervisory Board has access to the books, records and
offices of the Company in so far as required or as is useful for the proper
performance of his duties. The Supervisory Board member shall exercise this
right in consultation with the Chairman of the Supervisory Board and the
Company Secretary.
6.8 The Supervisory Board may in exercising its duties and after consultation
with the Chairman of the Managing Board, seek the assistance or advice of one
or more experts at a price agreed upon with the Supervisory Board, which is to
be paid by the Company.
7. Duties regarding the Activities of the Managing Board Members
7.1 The supervision of the Managing Board by the Supervisory Board shall
include: (i) achievement of the Company's objectives; (ii) the strategy and
risks inherent in the business activities; (iii) the structure and operation
of the internal risk managing and control systems; (iv) the financial
reporting process; (v) compliance with legislation and regulations.
7.2 The Supervisory Board supervises the financial reporting in accordance
with clause 10 of these Regulations.
7.3 The Supervisory Board shall discuss the corporate strategy and the risks
of the business, the result of the evaluation and assessment by the Managing
Board of the structure and operation of the internal risk managing and control
systems, as well as any significant changes thereto at least once a year.
7.4 The following resolutions of the Managing Board are subject to the
approval of the Supervisory Board:
(a) determining the operational and financial objectives of the Company;
(b) determining and amending the strategy designed to achieve the objectives;
(c) determining and amending the parameters to be applied in relation to the
strategy (for example in respect of the financial ratios); and
(d) the resolutions listed in Annex 4.
7.5 The Managing Board shall provide the Supervisory Board with the following
reports in a timely manner:
- for each meeting, a report with information on, among other things, mergers
and acquisitions, material developments, major organisational issues,
regulatory developments and other relevant issues; and
- for each meeting and quarterly, a report with detailed information on the
financial situation and development of the Company and its Subsidiaries,
which will be drafted in the format agreed upon from time to time between the
Managing Board and the Supervisory Board.
8. Duties regarding the Members and the Performance of the Supervisory Board
and Managing Board
8.1 The duties of the Supervisory Board regarding the members of the Managing
Board specifically include:
(a) the selection and nomination of members of the Managing Board, the
submission of proposals for the remuneration policy for members of the
Managing Board to the General Meeting of Shareholders, the determination of
the remuneration (in accordance with said remuneration policy) and the
contractual employment conditions of Managing Board members;
(b) the determination of the number of Managing Board members, the designation
of the Chairman and Vice-Chairman of the Managing Board, approving (or
proposing, where appropriate) of changes to the division of tasks within the
Managing Board or of the Regulations of the Managing Board and the review and
assessment of the functioning of the Managing Board and its individual
members; the approval of additional positions of the Managing Board to the
extent required under the Regulations of the Managing Board; and
(c) to address conflict of interest issues between the Company and members of
the Managing Board.
8.2 The duties of the Supervisory Board in relation to the members of the
Supervisory Board specifically include:
(a) the selection and nomination of members of the Supervisory Board (the
appointment is made by the General Meeting of Shareholders) and proposals to
the General Meeting of Shareholders for the remuneration of members of the
Supervisory Board;
(b) the determination of the number of Supervisory Board members, the
appointment of a Chairman and Vice-Chairman of the Supervisory Board, the
establishment of Committees and defining their role, the evaluation and
assessment of the functioning of the Supervisory Board, its Committees and the
individual members of the Supervisory Board (including an evaluation of the
Supervisory Board Profile and the induction, education and training
programme); the approval of other positions of Supervisory Board members to
the extent required under clause 22 of these Regulations; and
(c) to address conflict of interest issues between the Company and members of
the Supervisory Board.
8.3 At least once a year the Supervisory Board shall, without the Managing
Board being present, discuss its own functioning, and that of its individual
members, and the conclusions that must be drawn on the basis thereof. The
desired profile, composition and competence of the Supervisory Board shall
also be discussed. At least once a year the Supervisory Board shall also,
without the Managing Board being present, discuss the functioning of the
Managing Board as a body and the functioning of its individual members, and
the conclusions that must be drawn on the basis thereof.
9. Certain other Duties of the Supervisory Board
9.1 The other duties of the Supervisory Board include:
(a) duties regarding the External Auditor as described in clause 11 of these
Regulations and the Charter of the Audit Committee;
(b) the handling of complaints about alleged irregularities regarding the
functioning of members of the Managing Board;
(c) the taking of measures for the temporary managing of the Company if a
member of the Managing Board is absent or prevented from performing his duties;
(d) other duties the Supervisory Board is charged with under legislation, the
Company’s articles of association, these Regulations, the Charter of a
Committee or the Regulations of the Managing Board.
9.2 The Supervisory Board shall draw up a report to be included in the annual
statement of the Company) describing its activities in the financial year
concerned and containing the specific statements and information listed in
Annex 5.
9.3 The Supervisory Board and the Managing Board are jointly responsible for
the corporate governance structure of the Company, compliance with the Dutch
Corporate Governance Code and any other applicable legislation and regulations.
10. Supervision of Financial Reporting
10.1 The Supervisory Board supervises compliance with internal procedures
established by the Managing Board for the preparation and publication of the
Annual Report, the Annual Accounts, the quarterly and half-yearly figures and
ad hoc financial information. The Supervisory Board also supervises the
establishment and maintenance of internal control mechanisms for external
financial reporting as described in clause 7.1 of the Regulations of the
Managing Board.
10.2 The Audit Committee shall regularly, and in any event as soon as
possible, provide the Supervisory Board with reports on the Annual Report, the
Annual Accounts, and the quarterly and half-yearly figures, which will then be
discussed at a meeting of the Supervisory Board. The Annual Accounts and the
Annual Report for the year just ended shall be discussed in a meeting with the
Supervisory Board within five months of this year end. The half-yearly and
quarterly accounts of the Company for the respective period just ended shall
be discussed in a meeting of the Managing Board with the Supervisory Board.
10.3 The External Auditor shall in any event attend the part of the meeting of
the Supervisory Board at which the report of the External Auditor with respect
to the audit of the Annual Accounts is discussed, and at which a decision will
be taken on the adoption of the Annual Accounts. The External Auditor shall
receive the financial information underlying the adoption of the quarterly
and/or half-yearly figures, and other interim financial reports, and shall be
given the opportunity to respond to all information. The External Auditor
shall report his findings in relation to the audit of the Annual Accounts to
the Managing Board and the Supervisory Board simultaneously.
10.4 The line of contact between the Supervisory Board and the External
Auditor is in principle through the Chairman of the Audit Committee of the
Supervisory Board. The Audit Committee is the first contact for the External
Auditor if any irregularities in the contents of the financial reports are
discovered.
10.5 The Supervisory Board sees to it that the recommendations made by the
External Auditor are considered carefully by the Managing Board and the
Supervisory Board and, to the extent accepted, that they are actually carried
out by the Managing Board. This supervision may be delegated to the Audit
Committee of the Supervisory Board.
11. Duties regarding Nomination and Assessment of External Auditor
11.1 The External Auditor shall be appointed by the General Meeting of
Shareholders. The Supervisory Board nominates a candidate for this appointment
to the General Meeting of Shareholders and may recommend replacement of the
External Auditor. The Managing Board and the Audit Committee shall both advise
the Supervisory Board in this regard.
11.2 The remuneration of the External Auditor, and instructions to the
External Auditor to provide non-audit services, shall be approved by the
Supervisory Board on the recommendation of the Audit Committee, and after
consultation with the Managing Board.
11.3 The Managing Board and the Audit Committee shall report their dealings
with the External Auditor to the Supervisory Board on an annual basis,
including their assessment of the External Auditor's independence (for
example, the desirability of rotating the responsible partners of the External
Auditor and the desirability of the External Auditor providing both auditing
and non-audit services to the Company). The Supervisory Board shall take this
into account when deciding its nomination to the General Meeting of
Shareholders for the appointment of an External Auditor.
11.4 At least once every four years the Managing Board and the Audit Committee
shall conduct a thorough evaluation and assessment of the functioning of the
External Auditor in the various entities and capacities in which the External
Auditor acts. The main conclusions of this assessment are communicated to the
General Meeting of Shareholders.
11.5 Conflicts of interest and potential conflicts of interest between the
External Auditor and the Company shall be resolved in accordance with the
policy laid down in Annex 6 or, to the extent not dealt with in this Annex, in
the manner determined by the Supervisory Board at the recommendation of the
Audit Committee. Managing Board members and Supervisory Board members must
inform the chairman of the Audit Committee of issues that may compromise the
required independence of the External Auditor or that may give rise to a
conflict of interest or a potential conflict of interest between the External
Auditor and the Company, when brought to their attention.
11.6 When appointed, the External Auditor is requested to state explicitly to
the Company that he has been informed of: (i) the Company's policy as laid
down in clause 11.5 and Annex 6; and (ii) other matters provided for in the
Managing Board Regulations, these Regulations and the Charter of the Audit
Committee, that he agrees with and will co-operate fully with their
implementation.
12. Remuneration of Managing Board Members
12.1 The Nomination and Remuneration Committee shall annually on behalf of the
Supervisory Board prepare a Remuneration Report, which contains an account of
the manner in which the remuneration policy has been implemented in the past
financial year, as well as an overview of the remuneration policy for Managing
Board members planned by the Supervisory Board for the next financial year and
subsequent years. The Remuneration Report is posted on the Company’s website.
12.2 The remuneration policy planned for the next financial year and
subsequent years as specified in the Remuneration Report shall be submitted to
the General Meeting of Shareholders for adoption. Every change to the
remuneration policy shall also be submitted to the General Meeting of
Shareholders for its approval. Schemes whereby Managing Board members are
remunerated in the form of shares or rights to subscribe for shares, and major
changes to such schemes, shall be submitted to the General Meeting of
Shareholders for approval.
12.3 The Supervisory Board shall determine the remuneration of the individual
Managing Board members on a proposal by the Nomination and Remuneration
Committee, within the scope of the remuneration policy adopted by the General
Meeting of Shareholders.
12.4 The main features of the contract of a Managing Board member with the
Company for appointments as from January 1, 2004 shall be disclosed
immediately after its conclusion by publication on the Company's website. The
features disclosed are in any event the amount of the fixed salary, the
structure and amount of the variable remuneration component, any redundancy
scheme, pension arrangements and performance criteria.
12.5 If a Managing Board member or former Managing Board member is paid
special remuneration or compensation during a given financial year, an
explanation of this remuneration or compensation must be included in the
Remuneration Report. The Remuneration Report shall in any event account for
and explain remuneration paid or promised by way of severance pay in the year
under review to a Managing Board member.
13. Relation with the Shareholders
13.1 Where appropriate, the Supervisory Board shall provide all shareholders
and other parties in the financial markets with equal and simultaneous
information about matters that may influence the share price.
13.2 The Managing Board and the Supervisory Board shall provide the General
Meeting of Shareholders with all information that it requires for the exercise
of its powers.
13.3 The Managing Board and the Supervisory Board shall endeavour to procure
that the General Meeting of Shareholders is provided with all requested
information, unless this would be contrary to an overriding interest of the
Company. If the Managing Board or the Supervisory Board invoke an overriding
interest, they must give reasons.
13.4 If a right of approval is granted to the General Meeting of Shareholders
by law or the articles of association (for instance in the case of option
schemes, far-reaching decisions as referred to in Section 2:107a Dutch Civil
Code), or the Managing Board or the Supervisory Board requests a delegation of
powers (e.g. issue of shares or authorisation for the repurchase of shares),
the Managing Board and the Supervisory Board shall inform the general meeting
of shareholders by means of a shareholders' circular of all facts and
circumstances relevant to the approval, delegation or authorisation to be
granted. The shareholders' circular shall in any event be posted on the
Company's website as of the convening of the General Meeting of Shareholders,
at which the proposal concerned is discussed, until the meeting has ended.
This shareholders’ circular may be in the format of explanatory notes to the
agenda of the General Meeting of Shareholders.
13.5 The Managing Board and the Supervisory Board ensure compliance with all
applicable legislation and regulations with respects to the rights of the
General Meeting of Shareholders and the related rights of individual
shareholders.
13.6 The members of the Supervisory Board shall be present at the General
Meetings of Shareholders, unless they are unable to attend for important
reasons.
13.7 The General Meetings of Shareholders are presided over by the Chairman of
the Supervisory Board or, in his absence, the Vice-Chairman of the Supervisory
Board. The Supervisory Board may designate someone else to preside over the
meeting.
13.8 The Supervisory Board shall endeavour that a report of the General
Meeting of Shareholders is made available to the shareholders of the Company
by publication on the Company’s website no later than three months after the
end of the meeting, following which the shareholders have another three months
in which to respond to the report. The report is then adopted in the manner
provided for in the Company’s articles of association, by the Chairman and the
Secretary of the meeting. The provisions of this clause 13.8 may be
disregarded if a notarial deed is drawn up of the minutes of the proceedings.
After adoption the report is posted as soon as possible on the Company’s
website, in any case before the end of the first next held General Meeting of
Shareholders. Also, resolutions adopted by the General Meeting of Shareholders
are posted on the Company’s website as soon as possible after the meeting, in
any event before the end of the first next held General meeting of
Shareholders.
13.9 A resolution of the General Meeting of Shareholders may be disclosed
externally through a statement from the Chairman of the Supervisory Board or
the Company Secretary.
13.10 The Supervisory Board and the Managing Board shall procure that each
substantial change to the corporate governance structure of the Company, or
the compliance of the Company with the Dutch Corporate Governance Code, is
submitted to the General Meeting of Shareholders for discussion under a
separate agenda item.
13.11 The Supervisory Board sees to it that the responsible partner
(certifying auditor) of the firm of the External Auditor is present at the
General Meeting of Shareholders and that he can address the meeting. The
External Auditor may be questioned by the General Meeting of Shareholders in
relation to his statement on the fairness of the annual accounts.
Chapter 3
Supervisory Board meetings; decision-making
14. Frequency, Notice, Agenda and Venue of Meetings
14.1 The Supervisory Board shall meet as often as deemed necessary for the
proper functioning of the Supervisory Board. The Supervisory Board shall meet
at least 5 times a year. Meetings shall be scheduled annually as much as
possible in advance. The Supervisory Board shall also meet earlier than
scheduled if this is deemed necessary by the Chairman of the Supervisory
Board, two other members of the Supervisory Board, or the Managing Board.
14.2 Meetings of the Supervisory Board are in principle called by the Company
Secretary, in consultation with the Chairman. Save in urgent cases to be
determined by the Chairman the agenda for a meeting shall be sent to all
Supervisory Board members at least five calendar days before the meeting. For
each item on the agenda an explanation in writing shall be provided, where
possible, and/or other related documentation will be attached. The Chairman
shall in principle consult on the content of the agenda with the Chairman of
the Managing Board prior to convening the meeting.
14.3 Each Supervisory Board member, the Chairman of the Managing Board, and
the Managing Board collectively, has the right to request that an item be
placed on the agenda for a Supervisory Board meeting.
14.4 Supervisory Board meetings are generally held at the offices of the
Company, but may also take place elsewhere. In addition, meetings of the
Supervisory Board may be held by conference call, video conference or by any
other means of communication, provided all participants can communicate with
each other simultaneously.
15. Attendance of and Admittance to Meetings
15.1 The members of the Managing Board shall attend as many of the Supervisory
Board meetings as possible, to the extent the Supervisory Board does not
indicate that it wishes to meet alone.
15.2 A Supervisory Board member may be represented at Supervisory Board
meetings by another Supervisory Board member holding a proxy in writing. The
existence of such authorisation must be proved satisfactorily to the chairman
of the meeting.
15.3 If a Supervisory Board member is frequently absent from Supervisory Board
meetings he shall be called to account for this by the Chairman.
15.4 The admittance to the meeting of persons other than Supervisory Board
members, the Company Secretary and - if invited - members of the Managing
Board shall be decided by majority vote of the Supervisory Board members
present at the meeting.
16. Chairman of the Meeting; Reports
16.1 Supervisory Board meetings are presided over by the Chairman of the
Supervisory Board or, in his absence, the Vice-Chairman. If both are absent,
one of the other Supervisory Board members, designated by a majority of votes
cast by the Supervisory Board members present at the meeting, shall preside.
16.2 The Company Secretary or any other person designated for such purpose by
the chairman of the meeting shall draw up a report on the proceedings at the
meeting. The report should provide insight into the decision-making process at
the meeting. The report shall be adopted by the Supervisory Board at the next
meeting.
17. Decision-making within the Supervisory Board
17.1 The Supervisory Board members shall endeavour to achieve that resolutions
are, as much as possible, adopted unanimously.
17.2 Each Supervisory Board member has the right to cast one vote.
17.3 Where unanimity cannot be reached and the law, the Company’s articles of
association or these Regulations do not prescribe a larger majority, all
resolutions of the Supervisory Board are adopted by an absolute majority of
the votes cast. In the event of a tie, the Chairman of the Supervisory Board
has the deciding vote. At a meeting, the Supervisory Board may only pass
resolutions if the majority of the Supervisory Board members are present or
represented.
17.4 In general, resolutions of the Supervisory Board are adopted at a
Supervisory Board meeting.
17.5 Supervisory Board resolutions may also be adopted in writing, provided
the proposal concerned is submitted to all Supervisory Board members then in
office and none of them objects to this form of adoption. Adoption of
resolutions in writing shall be effected by statements in writing from all the
Supervisory Board members. A statement from a Supervisory Board member who
wishes to abstain from voting on a particular resolution which is adopted in
writing must reflect the fact that he does not object to this form of adoption.
17.6 The Supervisory Board may deviate from the provisions of clauses 17.3
(last sentence), 17.4 and 17.5 if this is deemed necessary by the Chairman of
the Supervisory Board, considering the urgent nature and other circumstances
of the case, provided that all Supervisory Board members are allowed the
opportunity to participate in the decision-making process. The Chairman of the
Supervisory Board and the Company Secretary shall then prepare a report on a
resolution so adopted, which shall be added to the documents for the next
meeting of the Supervisory Board.
17.7 A resolution adopted by the Supervisory Board may be evidenced outside
the Company through a statement from the Chairman of the Supervisory Board
and/or the Company Secretary.
Chapter 5
Other provisions
18. Conflicts of Interests of Supervisory Board Members
18.1 A Supervisory Board member shall immediately report any conflict of
interest or potential conflict of interest that is of material significance to
the Company and/or to him to the Chairman of the Supervisory Board and shall
provide all relevant information, including information concerning his spouse,
registered partner or other life companion, foster child and relatives by
blood or marriage up to the second degree. The Supervisory Board member
concerned shall not take part in the assessment by the Supervisory Board of
whether a conflict of interest exists.
18.2 A conflict of interest exists, in any event, if the Company intends to
enter into a transaction with a legal entity: (i) in which a Supervisory Board
member personally has a material financial interest; (ii) which has a
management board member who has a relationship under family law with a
Supervisory Board member; or (iii) in which a Supervisory Board member has a
managerial or supervisory position.
18.3 A Supervisory Board member shall not take part in any discussion or
decision-making that involves a subject or transaction in relation to which he
has a conflict of interest with the Company.
18.4 All transactions in which there are conflicts of interest with
Supervisory Board members shall be agreed on terms that are customary for
arm's-length transactions in the branch of business in which the Company and
its Subsidiaries operate. Decisions to enter into transactions in which there
are conflicts of interest with Supervisory Board members that are of material
significance to the Company and/or to the relevant Supervisory Board members
require the approval of the Supervisory Board.
19. Remuneration of Supervisory Board Members
19.1 The remuneration of the Supervisory Board members is determined by the
General Meeting of Shareholders. The Supervisory Board shall from time to time
submit proposals on its remuneration to the General Meeting of Shareholders.
If a Supervisory Board member is required to charge VAT on his fees, this will
be paid by the Company.
19.2 The remuneration of a Supervisory Board member may not depend on the
results of the Company. A Supervisory Board member shall not be granted any
shares and/or rights to shares in the Company's capital by way of remuneration.
19.3 Apart from their remuneration, Supervisory Board members shall be
reimbursed for all reasonable costs incurred in connection with their
attendance of meetings, the reasonableness of such costs being assessed by the
Chairman of the Supervisory Board (costs incurred by the Chairman of the
Supervisory Board are assessed by the Vice-Chairman). Any other expenses are
only reimbursed, in whole or in part, if incurred with the consent of the
Chairman or the Company Secretary on his behalf (or if it concerns the
Chairman, the Vice-Chairman or the Company Secretary on his behalf).
19.4 The Company and its Subsidiaries do not grant personal loans, guarantees
or the like to Supervisory Board members, save as part of its usual business
operations. Loans are not remitted.
20. Induction Programme, Ongoing Training and Education
20.1 Upon appointment, a Supervisory Board member shall follow an induction
programme that covers general financial and legal affairs, financial reporting
by the Company, any specific aspects unique to the Company and its business
activities, and the responsibilities of a Supervisory Board member.
20.2 The Supervisory Board shall conduct an annual review to identify any
aspects with regard to which the Supervisory Board members require further
training or education during their term of office.
20.3 The induction course, training and education shall be facilitated and
paid for by the Company.
21. Other Positions
21.1 Members of the Supervisory Board shall limit the number and nature of
their other positions so as to ensure due performance of their duties as
members of the Supervisory Board. They will hold no more than five memberships
of supervisory boards in Dutch listed companies, with a chairmanship counted
twice.
21.2 Supervisory Board members must inform the Chairman of the Supervisory
Board and the Company Secretary of their other positions which may be of
importance to the Company or the performance of their duties before accepting
such positions. If the Chairman determines that there is a risk of a conflict
of interest, the matter shall be discussed by the Supervisory Board in
accordance with clause 18 of these Regulations. The Company Secretary shall
keep a list of the outside positions concerned of each Supervisory Board
member.
22. Holding and Trading Securities
22.1 Any shareholding in the Company by Supervisory Board members is for the
purpose of long-term investment.
22.2 Supervisory Board members are bound to the DSM-Rules concerning Inside
Information of the Company regarding securities of the Company and other
securities referred to in those rules. The DSM-Rules concerning Inside
Information are posted on the Company’s website.
22.3 With respect to the ownership of and transactions with any securities
Supervisory Board members must at all times comply with all Dutch and foreign
statutory provisions and regulations applicable thereto.
22.4 A Supervisory Board member shall once a quarter report to the Corporate
Compliance Officer (as referred to in the DSM-Rules concerning Inside
Information) all changes in his holding of securities related to Dutch listed
companies which have occurred during the quarter preceding the relevant
report. However, such report need not be made if during the quarter concerned
he has invested exclusively in listed investment funds or has transferred the
discretionary management of his securities portfolio to an independent third
party by means of a written mandate agreement. In that case, the report must
state that this exemption applied without interruptions during the entire
quarter concerned. If the exemption is applied on the basis of the transfer of
the discretionary management of the securities portfolio to an independent
third party, the name and office address of the third party concerned must be
reported and a copy of the agreement with such third party must be submitted.
The information provided to the Corporate Compliance Officer under this clause
22.4 shall be part of the register referred to in the DSM-Rules concerning
Inside Information in respect of transactions in DSM securities. The Corporate
Compliance Officer shall report annually to the Chairman of the Managing Board
and the Chairman of the Supervisory Board.
23. Confidentiality
23.1 No Supervisory Board member shall, during his membership of the
Supervisory Board or afterwards, disclose in any way whatsoever to anyone
whomsoever any information of a confidential nature regarding the business of
the Company and/or any companies in which it holds a stake, that came to his
knowledge in the capacity of his work for the Company and which he knows or
should know to be of a confidential nature, unless required by law. A
Supervisory Board member is allowed to disclose the above information to
Managing Board members and Supervisory Board members as well as to staff
members of the Company and companies in which the Company holds a stake who,
in view of their activities for the Company and companies in which the Company
holds a stake, should be informed of the information concerned. A Supervisory
Board member shall not in any way whatsoever utilise the information referred
to above for his personal benefit.
24. Miscellaneous
24.1 Acceptance by Supervisory Board members. Anyone who is appointed as a
Supervisory Board member must, upon assuming office, declare in writing to the
Company that he accepts and agrees to the contents of these Regulations and
pledge to the Company that he will comply with the provisions of these
Regulations.
24.2 Occasional non-compliance. Subject to applicable law and regulation, the
Supervisory Board may occasionally decide at its sole discretion not to comply
with these Regulations. Any material non-compliance with these Regulations
shall be mentioned in the Annual Supervisory Board Report.
24.3 Amendment. These Regulations may be amended by the Supervisory Board at
its sole discretion without prior notification. Prior to amendment of these
Regulations the Managing Board shall be consulted.
24.4 Interpretation. In case of uncertainty or difference of opinion on how a
provision of these Regulations should be interpreted, the opinion of the
Chairman of the Supervisory Board shall be decisive.
24.5 Governing law and jurisdiction. These Regulations are governed by the
laws of the Netherlands. The courts of the Netherlands have exclusive
jurisdiction to settle any dispute arising from or in connection with these
Regulations (including any dispute regarding the existence, validity or
termination of these rules).
24.6 Complimentary to Dutch law and Articles of Association. These Regulations
are complementary to the provisions governing the Supervisory Board as
contained in Dutch law, other applicable Dutch, or EU regulations and the
Company’s articles of association. Where these Regulations are inconsistent
with Dutch law, other applicable Dutch or EU rules and regulations or the
Company’s articles of association, the latter shall prevail. Where these
Regulations are consistent with the Company’s articles of association but
inconsistent with Dutch law or other applicable Dutch or EU rules and
regulations, the latter shall prevail.
24.7 Partial invalidity. If one or more provisions of these Regulations are or
become invalid, this shall not affect the validity of the remaining
provisions. The Supervisory Board may replace the invalid provisions by
provisions which are valid and the effect of which, given the contents and
purpose of these Regulations is, to the greatest extent possible, similar to
that of the invalid provisions.
* * * * *
Annex 1
List of definitions
1. In the Regulations of the Managing Board and the Supervisory Board, the
following terms have the following meanings:
Affiliated company has the meaning attributed to it in Section 1 of the
Disclosure of Major Holdings in Listed Companies Act 1996 (Wet melding
zeggenschap in ter beurze genoteerde vennootschappen 1996).
Annual Accounts means the annual accounts of the Company as referred to in
Section 2:101 of the Dutch Civil Code.
Annual Report means the annual report of the Company drawn up by the Managing
Board, as referred to in Section 2:101 of the Dutch Civil Code.
Audit Committee means the Committee designated as such in clause 5 of the
Regulations of the Supervisory Board.
Regulations means the By-Laws of the Managing Board or the Regulations of the
Supervisory Board, depending on the context, including the annexes belonging
thereto.
Committee means, as regards the Supervisory Board, each committee of the
Supervisory Board as referred to in clause 5 of the Regulations of the
Supervisory Board.
Company means Koninklijke DSM N.V., and, where appropriate, the subsidiaries
and possible other group companies of the Company, whose financial information
is incorporated in the consolidated annual accounts of the Company.
External Auditor means the accounting and auditing firm that, in accordance
with Section 2:393 of the Dutch Civil Code, is charged with the audit of the
annual accounts of the Company.
General Meeting of Shareholders means the general meeting of shareholders of
the Company.
Group company has the meaning attributed to it in Section 2:24b of the Dutch
Civil Code.
In writing means by letter, by telecopier, by e-mail, or by message which is
transmitted via any other current means of communication and which can be
received in written form.
Managing Board means the Managing board of the Company.
Nomination & Remuneration Committee means the Committee designated as such in
clause 5 of the Regulations of the Supervisory Board.
Remuneration Report means the remuneration report of the Supervisory Board
regarding the remuneration policy of the Company as drawn up by the Nomination
and Remuneration Committee of the Supervisory Board.
Subsidiary has the meaning attributed to it in Section 2:24a of the Dutch
Civil Code.
Supervisory Board means the supervisory board of the Company.
Supervisory Board Profile means the profile for the size and composition of
the Supervisory Board, as designated in clause 1.1 of the Regulations of the
Supervisory Board.
2. Save where the context dictates otherwise, in the Regulations of the
Managing Board and the Supervisory Board:
(a) words and expressions expressed in the singular form also include the
plural form, and vice versa;
(b) words and expressions expressed in the masculine form also include the
feminine form; and
(c) a reference to a statutory provision counts as a reference to this
statutory provision including all amendments, additions and replacing
legislation that may apply from time to time.
3. Headings of articles and other headings in the Regulations of the Managing
Board and the Supervisory Board are inserted for ease of reference and do not
form part of the Regulations concerned for the purpose of interpretation.
Annex 2
List of information to be included in the annual
report
II.1.2 CG Code The broad outline of: (i) the operational and financial
objectives of the Company, (ii) the strategy designed to achieve the
objectives and (iii) the parameters to be applied in relation to the strategy.
II.1.4 CG Code A statement from the Managing Board that the internal risk
managing and control systems are adequate and effective and report on the
operation of the internal risk managing and control system during the year
under review.
II.1.5 CG Code A report on the sensitivity of the results of the Company to
external factors and variables.
II.3.4 CG Code Publication of all transactions in which there are conflicts of
interest with Managing Board members that are of material significance to the
Company and/or the Managing Board members concerned.
III.6.3 CG Code Publication of all transactions in which there are conflicts
of interest with Supervisory Board members that are of material significance
to the Company and/or the Supervisory Board members concerned.
III.6.4 CG Code Publication of all transactions between the Company and legal
or natural persons who hold at least ten percent of the shares in the Company.
IV.3.9 CG Code A survey of all existing or potential anti-takeover measures
and also an indication of the circumstances in which it is expected that these
measures may be used.
I.1 CG Code In a separate chapter: the broad outline of the corporate
governance structure of the Company, partly by reference to the principles
mentioned in the Dutch Corporate Governance Code, indicating expressly to what
extent it applies the best practice provisions in the Dutch Corporate
Governance Code and, in the event of non-appliance, why, and to what extent,
it does not apply it. After the first comprehensive description the status
compared with the Dutch Corporate Governance Code only has to be described in
future annual reports if changes have occurred.
A reference to the Managing Board resolutions pursuant to clauses 20.2 and
20.3 of the Regulations of the Managing Board, to the extent of material
significance.
Notes of the annual accounts
II.2 (2nd Principle)
CG Code The information prescribed by law on the level and structure of the
remuneration of the individual members of the Managing Board.
II.2.14 CG Code In addition to the information to be included pursuant to
Section 2:383d of the Dutch Civil Code, a statement of the value of the
options granted to the Managing Board members and the employees and an
indication of how this value is determined.
III.7 CG Code The information prescribed by law on the level and structure of
the remuneration of the individual members of the Supervisory Board.
Annex 3
Rotation plan Supervisory Board
| NAME | DATE FIRST APPOINTMENT | TERM EXPIRES | RE-APPOINTMENT POSSIBLE |
|
C.A.J. Herkströter (Chairman)
|
2000
|
2012
|
No
|
|
P. Hochuli
|
2005
|
2013
|
Yes
|
|
E. Kist
|
2004
|
2012
|
Yes
|
|
C. Sonder
|
2005
|
2013
|
Yes
|
|
T. de Swaan
|
2006
|
2010
|
Yes
|
|
C. van Woudenberg
|
1998
|
2010
|
No
|
|
L. Gunning-Schepers
|
2008
|
2012
|
Yes
|
Annex 4
List of approvals Supervisory Board
The approval of the Supervisory Board is required for:
(a) the allocation of duties of the Managing Board to individual members of
the Managing Board;
(b) all transactions between the Company and natural or legal persons who hold
at least 10% of the shares in the Company that are of material significance to
the Company and/or such persons;
(c) a resolution on the operational and financial aims of the company, the
strategy designed to achieve the aims, and the parameters to be applied in
relation to the strategy;
(d) all transactions in which there are conflicts of interest with Managing
Board members that are of material significance to the Company and/or the
relevant Managing Board members;
(e) all transactions in which there are conflicts of interest with Supervisory
Board members that are of material significance to the Company and/or the
relevant Supervisory Board members;
(f) the appointment and dismissal of the Company Secretary;
(g) all transactions by the Company or any of its Affiliated companies
regarding acquisition, divesture or joint venture projects with an invested
capital (plus goodwill) of € 30 million;
(h) the annual Capital Budget (and a semi-annual revision). Investment
projects not included in the Capital Budget and acquisitions/divestments of
assets are submitted if they exceed € 30 million;
(i) lay-offs by any of the Affiliated companies in excess of 100 persons
within a 3 month period;
(j) the corporate Annual Strategic Review (ASR);
(k) the annual Financing Plan (and its semi-annual revision);
(l) guarantees concerning non-consolidated companies if the value exceeds € 30
million.
Annex 5
List of information to be included in the
Supervisory Board report
(1) a reference to the discussions on the corporate strategy and business
risks, and the result of the assessment by the Managing Board of the structure
and operation of the internal risk managing and control systems, as well as
any significant changes thereto, which were held by the Supervisory Board in
the year under review;
(2) a list of the Supervisory Board members who have often been absent from
Supervisory Board meetings;
(3) a statement that in the opinion of the Supervisory Board clause 1.3(f) of
the Regulations of the Supervisory Board have been satisfied and which member
of the Supervisory Board, if present, should not be deemed independent;
(4) a reference to the discussions described in clause 8.3 of the Regulations
of the Supervisory Board;
(5) a reference to the Supervisory Board resolutions pursuant to clauses 24.2
and 24.3 of the Regulations of the Supervisory Board, to the extent of
material significance;
(6) for each Committee: a report on how it has performed its duties; details
of its existence, its composition, number of meetings and the main issues
discussed;
(7) the following information on each Supervisory Board member: (i) age ; (ii)
nationality; (iii) date of initial appointment and term of appointment; (iv)
chief position; (v) other positions, to the extent relevant for the
performance of his duties as member of the Supervisory Board; (vi) securities
held in the Company; (vii) details of agreements under which benefits are
derived on termination of membership of the Supervisory Board or any other
position at the Company; (viii) gender; (ix) profession; and
(8) the principal points of the Remuneration Report on the remuneration policy
of the Company, as prepared by the Remuneration Committee.
Annex 6
Policy regarding independent external auditor
The policy set out below was adopted by the Supervisory Board on September 8,
2004, on a proposal of the Audit Committee and after consultation with the
Managing Board.
1. Policy
The Company and its Subsidiaries use the services of the External Auditor to
the extent this does not prejudice the independence of the External Auditor.
2. Charter
The External Auditor must be independent within the meaning of the
Recommendation of the European Commission of 16 May 2002 regarding the
independence of auditors in the EU charged with statutory audits, and the
Further Regulations on the independence of auditors of the NIVRA (NIVRA
Regulations). These regulations are based on the principles that: (i) the
external auditor must be independent from the client audited, both in mind as
in appearance; and (ii) an external auditor is someone who is able, in the
light of all relevant facts and circumstances, to form an objective and
impartial opinion on all matters that fall within the scope of his assignment.
Under the NIVRA Regulations an external auditor is not allowed to perform a
statutory audit if he has financial, commercial, employment or other ties with
the client that in the opinion of a reasonable and properly informed third
party expert compromise the auditor's independence.
The Company may require from the external auditor that he maintains the right
balance between effectiveness and efficiency, e.g. audit costs, risk managing,
independence and reliability.
The Audit Committee sees to it that the external auditor complies with the
relevant provisions of the NIVRA Regulations and the above Charter, and may
request more detailed explanations and written confirmations from the external
auditor that these provisions are followed.
3. Approval of work
In addition to the audit work, the external auditor of the Company may also
carry out non-audit work, to the extent allowed under applicable legislation
and regulations and the internal procedures of the Company.
All audit and non-audit work (including fees and conditions) carried out by
the external auditor for the Company are subject to the remuneration and
instructions approved by the Supervisory Board on the recommendation of the
Audit Committee and after consultation with the Managing Board.
4. Work
A. Audit work
Audit work is the audit of the annual financial reports of the Company, the
assessment of interim financial reports that are disclosed, services that are
traditionally provided by the external auditor and that are related to filings
and obligations under legislation or regulations, and services that only the
external auditor as such can reasonably provide.
The External Auditor does not need to go through a tender process for each
individual engagement.
B. Non-audit work
For non-audit work of the External Auditor, the Supervisory Board shall on the
proposal of the Audit Committee set one or more financial thresholds. For
non-audit work by the external auditor that is expected to exceed these
thresholds, a tender process approved by the Audit Committee must be followed.
When assessing a request for the approval of non-audit work, the Audit
Committee shall see to it that the prohibitions and restrictions set by NIVRA
shall be observed with respect to the following categories of services, and if
so desired more information regarding this compliance will be requested from
the External Auditor:
(a) services
(b) design and implementation of financial information systems;
(c) valuation services;
(d) internal control services;
(e) legal services; and
(f) intermediary services for the recruitment of senior staff for client.
For further explanation whether certain activities should be considered audit
work or non-audit work and whether certain non-audit activities fall under any
of the categories listed above, the head of the operational audit department
should be contacted who, when in doubt, will consult the chairman of the Audit
Committee.
5. Rotation of partners responsible for audit work
In order to prevent that the external auditor and the Company become too
close, the number of years a person may be part of the audit team of the
External Auditor, is capped.
Partners of the audit team of the Company who are charged with essential audit
tasks must be replaced at most 7 years after the start of their involvement.
The partners of the audit team of the Company charged with essential tasks who
have been replaced are not allowed to work on a new assignment for the Company
until at least 2 years have expired from the date of their replacement.
The Audit Committee shall also supervise the risks of dependency of other
members of the audit team of the Company who are involved with the audit for a
significant period. The Audit Committee shall consult the responsible partner
of the external auditor regularly on safeguards set up by the external auditor
to assess the risk of dependency and to reduce it to an acceptable minimum
level.
6. Appointment of the External Auditor
The External Auditor shall be appointed in accordance with clause 11 of the
Regulations of the Supervisory Board. If the decision is taken to call in the
services of another External Auditor, the tender process approved by the Audit
Committee shall be followed.
7. Staff transfer restrictions
The Company and the External Auditor shall agree on a policy regarding the
restriction of staff transfers from the Company and its group to the
organisation of the External Auditor and vice versa, taking into account all
relevant legislation and regulations. This policy is subject to the approval
of the Supervisory Board.