This site uses cookies to store information on your computer. Learn more x


Providing perspectives on recent research into vitamins and nutritionals


Journalism Fails when Stories are not Adequately Verified

By Michael McBurney

Journalism, get your act together! Once again, print and televised media (Sunday Express, The Guardian, Daily Mail, CBS News) are disseminating a story which raises many questions. Only a few weeks since the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism investigation led Rolling Stone to apologize for failing to meet journalistic standards. What are today’s sordid details?

The American Association for Cancer Research is holding its annual meeting in Philadelphia, Apr 18-22. Dr Tim  Byers, University of Colorado Cancer Centre is reported to have presented evidence, after studying thousands of patients for ten years, that some people get more cancer while on vitamins. My problem is the apparent lack of peer-reviewed evidence with hazard ratios (HR) or odds ratios (OR), or even an abstract to partially substantiate the claim.

A session entitled “Dietary Supplements and Cancer Risk and Prognosis” was apparently held Monday, April 20 from 5-6:30pm. Dr Tim E Byers is listed as an invited speaker but there is no abstract for his presentation. The University of Colorado Cancer Center has promoted his research but an abstract, peer-reviewed paper, or supplemental data cannot be found. The question is, did journalists ask to see the scientific evidence? Certainly, I cannot make an evaluation without some scientific evidence beyond expert opinion.

This is some of the scientifically published literature on multivitamin/mineral supplementation and cancer risk. A systematic Review of 4 good-quality randomized controlled Trials (RCTs) (n=28,607) and one good-quality cohort study (n=72,337) found no evidence of harm with vitamin/mineral supplementation. In fact, daily multivitamin supplementation decreased risk of total cancer by 8% in the Physicians Health Study II (n=14,641). Breast cancer mortality was 30% lower in women using multivitamin/mineral supplements vs non-users (n=7,728).

The Heidelberg cohort of the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition (EPIC-Heidelberg) (n=23,943) did not find a statistically significant effect of vitamin/mineral supplementation on cancer risk (beneficial or harmful). It did find baseline users of antioxidant supplements had a 48% reduced risk of cancer mortality. Because of a ‘sick-user effect’, researchers are advised to be cautious that bias isn’t introduced with the conversion of 'sick' non-users to users-of-supplements during research studies.

Scientists are expected to be diligent. When conducting vitamin/mineral supplementation studies, it is reasonable to criticize reports that rely upon randomization (supplement vs placebo) without consideration of vitamin status, e.g. serum α-tocopherol concentrations, of the volunteers.

Failures in journalism are unacceptable. They mislead and erode public trust. The media has the freedom to conduct interviews and verify sources. Ask scientists and institutions if the data has undergone peer review. Interview experts who have reviewed the study and/or data.

Main Citation

Oh wait, there isn’t one!

Other Citations

Fortmann SP, Burda BU, Senger CA, Lin JS, Beil TL, O’Connor E, Whitlock EP. et al. Vitamin, Mineral, and Multivitamin Supplements for the Primary Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease and Cancer: A Systematic Evidence Review of the US Preventive Services Task Force. Rockville, MD. 2013 Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (US) Report No 14-051199-EF-1

Gaziano JM, Sesson HD, Christen WG, Bubes V, Smith JP, MacFadyen J, Schvartz M, Manson JE, Glynn RJ, Buring JE. Multivitamins in the prevention of cancer in men: The Physicians’ Health Study II Randomized Controlled Trial. 2012 JAMA doi: 10.1001/jama.2012.14641

Wassertheil-Smoller S, McGinn AP, Budrys N, Chiebowski HR, Ho GY, Johnson KC, Lane DS, Newhouser ML, Saquib J, Shikany JM, Song Y, Thomson C. Multivitamin and mineral use and breast cancer mortality in older women with invasive breast cancer in the women’s health initiative. 2013  Breast Cancer Res Treat doi: 10.1007/s10549-013-2712-x

Li K, Kaaks R, Linseisen J, Rohmann S. Vitamin/mineral supplementation and cancer, cardiovascular, and all-cause mortality in a German prospective cohort (EPIC-Heidelberg). 2012 Eur J Nutr doi: 10.1007/s00394-011-0224-1

You are signed in as:
whn May 11, 2017 10:57 AM
Under the snow peak, Zhuo is the lake. "Why? So why do this? I just want to be a mother, want to have a child of their own, but you are not willing to pay, every time you are affixed to the fine do not shoot, God, I hate you! I hate you! You are a ruthless selfish person. "A stunning woman stands in the water naked upper body, while crying while patting the lake, chest full of breasts with the body twist Rhythm of the shaking, emitting a white holy luster. The shore of a Qiu must go back and forth pacing, watching a woman in the water sprinkle soared, heart disgust: "You crazy woman, really want the child to be crazy, two people more comfortable, have children do? "Said the air Xiu Xiu turned away, and ignored the woman's crying. "Trained and trained !!" see her husband and ignore their own to leave alone, the woman heartbroken, crying for a while slowly came to the shore. "Call" Suddenly the lake rises in a bucket-like thick snake tail, snake body up to two scales scales glittering, the woman every step of the chest breast and snake around the swing is really good look, line to the lake only to find this stunning woman Turned out to be the first snake body, upper body naked near ten feet, the snake is more than two feet long, on the shore to drive clouds to the east away. Wanshan ancestors, the top of the Kunlun, jade virtual peak of a Tsing Yi old man sigh: "Oh! And quarreled, and nearly nearly eight thousand eight hundred and thirty back! I was this sister is really hard, married the fool Every day to know what Jiugong gossip, stood such a beautiful wife do not accompany the woman is the need to coax you! You do not have time to accompany her, according to her request to give birth to a child to the companion, but not willing to pay A trace of God, really a stubborn and selfish guy, three days to quarrel, has been quarreling for more than a million years, so when the day is a head ah? "Think of this thing between husband and wife is not easy to intervene , Helplessly shook his head and turned to the hole and walked. Line to the way suddenly paused the body, smile soon as: it seems trouble or come to the door, and want to hide can not hide ah! "Brother!" Midwive came a woman's call, come is just in the lake crying people first snake body stunning woman, the old man has always been feeling that the arrival of those who stopped to wait for. Old man slowly turned the body, asked to smile asked: "Shimei today how free to see my old man? Is not and Fuxi quarreled?" Women down the cloud Jiao Jiao said: "Brother, I am not a special trip to To see you, nor to listen to you say that thousands of times all the way, I just come to you to help find a child's way. "" What is the way to find my child! "Old man at the foot of a staggering," Shimei You still bypass my old bones it! If it was Fuxi know that it is not Grilled my skin. "The old man frightened, hand pendulum and rattle like. Woman's face crimson, snapped: "Brother, where do you want to go! Old right! I just come to you to find a child's magic, not to say that you and that ... ..." "What Old man gas beard Alice, Long said: "chaos beginning to this point, I have lived for three million years, and now alone or alone in vain, you! You actually said that I am not serious "The old man angry big sleeves flushed back, the woman was covered with" Puchi "smile. The original, the chaos opened to the beginning of this also five people, they are Hongjun, Pangu, Nu Wa, Pan Xing, Fu Xi, because Hongjun is the birth of the first world of wisdom, behind a few people more or less Have been educated by Hongjun, so everyone is consistent with the Hongjun respect for the big brother. Later Pangu and the plate Xing two fight for the brother of a war, then that war to play the darkness, broken mountains and rivers, sun and the moon without light, the final panic body into a towering Kunlun will be calm in the abyss, can be described as a lose-lose The Now this world also Hongjun, Nu Wa, Fu Xi three, this old man is Hongjun, the first snake body of the woman is of course Nu Wa. So this Hongjun think not single is immune, Nu Wa is laughing for this
0 Replies » Reply
Shoulder bags August 9, 2017 10:33 PM
Nice, very nice article. I will share it per my accounts
0 Replies » Reply target='_blank' style='color: #000; text-decoration: underline;'> target='_blank' style='color: #000; text-decoration: underline;'> target='_blank' style='color: #000; text-decoration: underline;'> target='_blank' style='color: #000; text-decoration: underline;'> target='_blank' style='color: #000; text-decoration: underline;'>
0 Replies » Reply